Teaching in the mother tongue or English

 The choice between teaching in the mother tongue or English in a technical college, such as a Polytechnic, involves various considerations, and the decision may depend on the specific context, goals, and resources of the institution. Below, I'll discuss different points to consider for both options:

1. Student Understanding and Communication:

   • Mother Tongue: Teaching in the mother tongue can enhance students' understanding, as they are more likely to be fluent in their native language. It minimizes language barriers, ensuring that complex technical concepts are easily grasped.
   • 
     
   • English: English is often considered a global language, and proficiency in English is valuable in the international job market. However, if students are not proficient, it may hinder effective communication and comprehension.

2. Global Competitiveness:

   • Mother Tongue: Focusing on the mother tongue might limit students' exposure to international technical literature and collaborations, potentially reducing their global competitiveness.
   • 
     
   • English: Teaching in English can prepare students for a globalized job market, giving them access to a vast pool of resources, research, and collaborations.

3. Quality of Educational Resources:

   • Mother Tongue: Availability of quality educational resources in the mother tongue may be limited, which could affect the depth and breadth of the curriculum.
   • 
     
   • English: English offers a wide range of technical resources, textbooks, and research publications, providing students with a broader knowledge base.

4. Industry Alignment:

   • Mother Tongue: In some regions, industries may predominantly use the local language. Teaching in the mother tongue can be aligned with the needs of the local job market.
   • 
     
   • English: Many multinational companies and industries use English as their primary language. Teaching in English can better align students with the requirements of these global industries.

5. Faculty Competency:

   • Mother Tongue: Faculty members may be more proficient and comfortable teaching in their mother tongue, leading to more effective communication and engagement.
   • 
     
   • English: If faculty members are proficient in English, it can enhance the quality of instruction and enable them to participate in global academic and research communities.

6. Government Policies and Support:

   • Mother Tongue: Some countries have policies promoting education in the mother tongue to preserve cultural identity.
   • 
     
   • English: In some regions, government policies may encourage or mandate the use of English in higher education to align with global standards.

7. Student Preferences:

   • Mother Tongue: Students might feel more comfortable and confident learning in their mother tongue, which can positively impact their motivation and engagement.
   • 
     
   • English: Some students may prefer learning in English, anticipating the benefits it brings in terms of global opportunities and career prospects.

8. Transition to Higher Education:

   • Mother Tongue: Students transitioning to higher education institutions where English is the primary language may face challenges in adapting to an English-medium curriculum.
   • 
     
   • English: Teaching in English can better prepare students for higher education opportunities globally, including pursuing advanced degrees in English-speaking countries.

Opinion:

The choice between teaching in the mother tongue and English ultimately depends on the specific context and goals of the technical college. A balanced approach, where students are proficient in both their mother tongue and English, could be ideal. This would involve teaching core technical concepts in the mother tongue while incorporating English-language components to prepare students for the globalized job market and advanced studies.

It's essential to assess the needs of the local industry, consider government policies, and ensure faculty competency in both language aspects. Providing additional support, such as language proficiency programs, can help bridge any gaps and ensure that students are well-prepared for both local and international opportunities.